Market vs. Desk

Archive: the 2026 midterms tracker no longer updates. Scores include every call logged; race charts show election night.

What Kalshi's own research says

Kalshi: midterms calibration and accuracy

Kalshi published its own scorecard the morning after. These are Kalshi's numbers, measured its own way, and they cover Kalshi only. This site measures both markets against DDHQ and AP with a different rule, so the figures here won't match the scoreboard.

479 of 487
races won by Kalshi's favorite, set before any votes were counted (98%)
115 min
average Kalshi lead over CNN in 11 key Senate races
0.0140
Kalshi's Brier score on 427 races, lowest of 11 forecasts (lower is better)

Kalshi vs. CNN in the Senate

Kalshi's first trade at 99¢ or higher vs. CNN's projection, ET

RaceKalshi 99¢CNNLead
Michigan10:23 PM2:28 AM+245m
Louisiana9:12 PM12:40 AM+208m
Nebraska12:24 AM3:39 AM+194m
Minnesota9:02 PM12:09 AM+187m
Texas8:28 PM10:59 PM+151m
Ohio (special)8:52 PM11:02 PM+130m
Kansas10:21 PM11:15 PM+54m
Florida (special)8:01 PM8:34 PM+34m
Maine11:45 PM12:17 AM+32m
Iowa11:07 PM11:36 PM+28m
South Carolina9:56 PM10:02 PM+6m

Times after midnight are Nov 4. Average lead: 115.4 minutes.

Forecast accuracy

Brier score on 427 races, including governors; lower is better

  • Kalshi0.0140
  • Silver Bulletin Deluxe0.0141
  • Silver Bulletin Classic0.0163
  • VoteHub0.0175
  • Model average0.0183
  • VoteHub Legacy0.0185
  • On Point0.0202
  • Race to the WH0.0209
  • Silver Bulletin Lite0.0210
  • DDHQ0.0234
  • Pollsmax0.0281

Model and Kalshi snapshots taken 9 AM on Election Day. On the 393 races without governors, Kalshi scored 0.0127 against a model average of 0.0167. Kalshi says it was more accurate than the model average in 77% of close races.

How often the favorite won

Share of 127 races won by Kalshi's favorite or each poll average's leader

Before Election Day3 months1 month1 week1 dayPolls open
Kalshi81%88%90%94%95%
VoteHub average77%80%81%85%85%
VoteHub simple average75%82%87%89%89%
Wikipedia simple average75%85%90%90%90%

Resolved as of 6:37 AM ET Nov 4: 28 Senate, 68 House and 31 governor races. On calibration, Kalshi reports that candidates priced near 50% when polls opened won about half the time, with the same pattern at other prices.

Why Kalshi's numbers differ from this site's